HAPPY HOUR ATLAS
The Pony Bar
Photo: Google Maps

Happy Hour

The Pony Bar

Upper East Side · Beer bar

GOOGLE★ 4.5823YELP★ 4403Google: higher than 31% of venues in New York City

The happy hour

Drinks

  • Draft beer — $7
  • Well drinks — $7
  • Wine by the glass — $7

Secret NYC, March 26, 2025: Monday–Friday 4:20–6:20pm, any draft, well drink, or wine by the glass for $7.

Deal last verified 2026-09-30.

The space

Photos: Google Maps

The vibe

A craft-beer bar on First Avenue. The window is two hours, starting at 4:20.

  • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Cozy
  • Hip
  • Good for groups
  • Google: happy hour drinks
  • Takes reservations

Is that score good?

Almost everywhere scores 4–5 stars, so each site's score is shown against every venue in the Atlas rated on that site — here in New York City, and across the US. The gold bar is this spot.

GOOGLE ★ 4.5 823 ratings ↗
In New York City 222 rated venues At the median

Rated higher than 31% · tied with 22% · lower than 47% of the others · median ★ 4.5

Across the US 2,042 rated venues At the median

Rated higher than 34% · tied with 23% · lower than 44% of the others · median ★ 4.5

YELP ★ 4 403 reviews ↗
In New York City 219 rated venues Below median

Rated higher than 27% · tied with 14% · lower than 59% of the others · median ★ 4.2

Across the US 1,993 rated venues Below median

Rated higher than 27% · tied with 11% · lower than 63% of the others · median ★ 4.1

Each bar counts venues at that rating (0.1-star steps), lowest on the left; the curve starts at the lowest score anyone has. Ratings captured October 7, 2026.

Getting there

1444 1st Ave, New York, NY 10021

More in Upper East Side