Secret NYC, March 26, 2025: every day 4:30–6:30pm, $1.50 East Coast oysters, select beer $6, wine and cocktails $9. A July 2026 listing described Monday all night and Tuesday–Sunday 4:30–6pm, with $2 oysters, $8 drafts, $10 wine, and $12 cocktails. The March 2025 window and prices are the ones on the card.
The Chelsea room of the Mermaid Inn group. The Times Square and Upper West Side cards are different locations.
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Cozy
Romantic
Hip
Good for groups
Known for cocktails
Known for wine
Google: happy hour drinks
Google: happy hour food
Takes reservations
Outdoor seating
Is that score good?
Almost everywhere scores 4–5 stars, so each site's score is shown against every venue in the Atlas rated on that site — here in New York City, and across the US. The gold bar is this spot.
Rated higher than 95% · tied with 4% · lower than 2% of the others
· median ★ 4.6
Across the US537 rated venuesTop quarter
3.03.54.04.5THIS SPOT4.85.0
Rated higher than 77% · tied with 17% · lower than 6% of the others
· median ★ 4.6
Each bar counts venues at that rating (0.1-star steps), lowest on the left; the curve starts at the lowest score anyone has. Ratings captured October 7, 2026.
